Society & culture · Work & money · Norway
The forty per cent rule
Twenty years ago Norway told its listed companies to fill their boards with women or lose their listing. It worked. It also showed exactly how much a law can and cannot change.
Ingrid Dahl · Norway · 8 min read
From the eleventh floor the harbour looks like a diagram: cranes, containers, one white ferry sliding out towards the fjord. Ingrid is fifty-two and sits on three boards, one of them listed. Twenty years ago, when she took her first seat, she was usually the only woman at the table and always the youngest. Now she counts four women around eight chairs, and finds herself, with some irritation, thinking that this is what normal was supposed to look like.
Norway did not arrive here by persuasion. In 2003 its parliament passed a rule that looked almost impudent: listed companies would have to fill 40 per cent of their board seats with women, and companies that refused could be struck off the register. It came into force for state-owned companies in 2006 and for public limited companies in 2008. Almost nobody believed it would be needed; almost everybody believed it would fail. Neither turned out to be true.
A door, not a corridor
Compliance was close to total, and the reason is unglamorous: the sanction was existential. No one wanted to be liquidated for the sake of a board seat. The proportion of women on the boards of listed companies went from around six per cent to the fortieth percentile in a few years, and it has stayed there. Germany, France, Iceland, Spain and others later wrote versions of the same law; Norway's was simply the first to make the threat real.
The quota did not change the culture first. It changed the seating plan, and the culture followed the seating plan. That is the whole trick.
The golden skirts
The critique has never gone away, and it is not stupid. Because the pool was shallow in 2005, the same women were invited onto several boards at once; the Norwegian press gave them a name, the golden skirts, and the image stuck. Some studies found boards became more formal, met more often and prepared harder. Others found that a law about representation had, in places, produced a small professional class of board members who sat on six or eight companies and knew each other's telephone numbers.
That is what a quota does when it arrives before the pipeline is ready. What it cannot do is what Ingrid is careful to distinguish from it: it cannot make a company promote women into the roles that lead to a board in the first place.
Where the law stopped
Among Norwegian listed companies, women now hold roughly a quarter of executive team positions, and a smaller share of chief executive posts. Progress, but at less than half the pace of the boardroom. The law covered a few hundred companies — a tiny slice of Norwegian working life — and said nothing about the family firm in Ålesund, the building trade, the part-time norm that still shapes women's working lives. Roughly a third of Norwegian women in work are part time, one of the higher rates in Europe, and the pay gap has narrowed only slowly.
What the quota did prove is narrower and more useful: that the argument about "not enough qualified women" was mostly an argument about where companies were looking. When the search changed, the women appeared.
The last brick
Ingrid is impatient with the idea that Norway is a country of natural enlightenment. The quota, she says, was the last brick, not the first. It landed on top of thirty years of public childcare, a parental leave system that gives fathers a non-transferable share of the leave, and a labour market where a mother returning to work was unremarkable. Without those, forcing boards open would have produced six angry women and a lot of newspaper columns.
Her daughter is twenty-four, an engineer in Trondheim, and finds the whole debate a little quaint. She has never been the only woman in a room, and does not intend to be the first woman in a boardroom either. "She thinks the fight is over," Ingrid says, watching the ferry clear the harbour wall. "I let her think it for a few more years."


